Do I need both life insurance and critical illness insurance?

Share

Because they cover different things, many Canadians do need both life and critical illness insurance. One protects your family after you're gone. The other protects your finances while you're still here.

Share

DEFINITIONS

    • Life insurance: A written picture of your income, debts, and savings, plus the steps to reach your financial goals.
    • Critical insurance coverage: A policy that pays a tax-free lump sum if you’re diagnosed with a covered condition — usually cancer, heart attack, or stroke — and survive the waiting period, often 30 days.
    • Waiting period: The survival period you must complete after diagnosis before the CI benefit is paid.

 

What each one actually does

Life insurance answers one question: If you were to die tomorrow, could the people relying on you pay the mortgage, the bills, and raise the kids without your income? A life insurance payout goes to your beneficiaries, and in Canada that money is generally received tax-free.

Critical illness insurance answers a different question: If you were diagnosed with a serious illness and needed to take time away from work, how would you replace that lost income? Provincial health plans cover hospital and doctor care, but they don’t cover your mortgage, your groceries, or the hospital parking – not to mention, any treatments that aren’t covered by your province. A critical illness payout can help cover these expenses, and you can use it however you choose.

In short, life insurance protects the people who depend on your income if you die. Critical illness insurance protects you if you’re diagnosed with a covered condition and survive the waiting period.

That’s why one doesn’t replace the other. A critical illness policy isn’t designed to pay out if you pass away, and a life insurance policy typically won’t hand you cash during treatment and recovery.

When both make sense

Both are worth considering if you have people who depend on your income – and they couldn’t easily get by for a long stretch without it. This can include most working parents, self-employed people, and anyone carrying a mortgage.

If budgets are tight, be honest about priorities. For many Canadians, life insurance comes first – because a death benefit can protect their family from a loss they can’t recover from. These same families may choose to add critical illness coverage later, or start with a smaller amount and increase it as their income allows.

Some insurers offer critical illness coverage as a rider on a life insurance policy. While this can keep costs down, the coverage is usually less than a standalone policy.

Still on the fence?

An easy way to look at is this: Life insurance covers the “after.” Critical illness insurance covers the “during.” For most families with a mortgage and kids, the question isn’t which one – it’s how much of each you can comfortably afford.

Let us help

Still have questions? Set up a call with one of our licensed advisors to ask about the details that matter.